To put it simply, what do savings groups offer that micro finance doesn’t?
All in Theory
Recent research has decisively challenged the perception that poor people do not save
The selection of specific saving vehicles is driven by three high-level choices.
Am I just blinded by my own enthusiasm? Or are savings groups, around for millennium in so many cultures including my own, really a globally good idea?
Yes, a goal we set in the same way that nutritionists suggest daily doses of vitamin A
There is something to this, even though the experiment that Kim describes is WEIRD.
...savings are transactions-in-waiting. People's aim is not to save or get into debt, what they want is to buy a bicycle, pay school fees, repair their home, or build up a reserve for medical emergencies.
Does adding a diet and cooking piece making savings groups more expensive? Yes! But, does it make groups more relevant, entertaining and powerful for women? Yes as well.
One of the good things about provocative writers like Milford Bateman is that... they provoke. Here's a cool head (Greg Pirie) writing about a hot head - a good short read.
What blocks the effortless transitioning from cash-based opportunities to secure, long-term investments? Cash. Cash must go.
Finally, Buddhist financial services would be inextricably linked to and supportive of all parts of a good life, including protection of the physical environment...
...the multiplication of so many little neighborhood clubs, whether or not their groupiness holds over time, does bring about the transformational change originally sought by the community. People are less isolated, happier, whole...
The attraction of using savings groups as the foundation for a cooperative business is no mystery. Unfortunate, that.
The savings group sector has the opportunity to avoid the growing pains of microcredit - the hype, the promulgation of unrepresentative and unattributable results, the focus on financial performance to the detriment of social performance, the upmarket drift. Will we seize that opportunity?
Who keeps the money safe? You decide.
How do we keep records? You decide. How does a new person join? You decide. What if somebody leaves? You decide. What do we do with the money? You decide,